There is debate about the benefit ( or lack ) of an IEP student with learning difficulties participating in a class-within-a-class (CWC) setting versus participating in a resource class. Parents need to be aware of the dynamic of CWC.
Some argue that some students with learning difficulties, especially deficits in functional memory and/or processing speed, are expected to benefit from being in a CWC setting. Perhaps they can, but to what extent does the benefit actually “benefit” the student? What are the benefits?
Perhaps some benefits for the student are:
- he gets to sit with non-disabled
- he has some expose to grade-level curricula
- on occasion gets support from the second teacher in the class
perhaps some benefits for the public school district are:
- Less costly because fewer staff/man hours for that student
- paperwork indicates student is in “least restrictive environment” (keeps up number for state reporting)
- student expected to learn content to prepare student for state standardized test
Perhaps some disadvantages for the student are:
- Student frustration since content moves quickly; seemingly more so for students with learning struggles
- stress of homework demands above/beyond those of non-disabled student
- unable to process all the information in class, thus increasing homework burden and lessens family/free time
- stresses on family to assist with homework, costs for tutor
- Stressors build to point of wanting to avoid school resulting in need for professional counseling
- Misses opportunity for skill building that he would have acquired in a self-contained setting
- Stigma of not fitting in either setting
- School might indicate they will drop the paraprofessional the student had prior to CWC
Perhaps some disadvantages for the public school are:
- Allowing students to fail in CWC then having to have an IEP meeting to explain to the parent that the student needs to be moved
- Teacher frustration since teachers see when students are struggling unnecessarily
- Students who become so frustrated that they cause behavior problems in the class thus disrupting other students
- Political wranglings among staff triggering a “regular-ed versus Special-ed” culture
Parents need to carefully consider if CWC is the setting that is appropriate for their child. High schools are known to do this since the expectations for the student are lowered when the student will “graduate” soon.
Complete the form below if you’d like a professional parent advocate from TheIEPCenter.com contact you.